A Comparative Investigation of TOPSIS, Factor Analysis, and Scale Gram Analytical Methods on Rural Development (A Case Study of Islamshahr Rural Development Level)

International Journal of Agricultural Management and Development

مقاله 2، دوره 9، شماره 2، شهریور 2019، صفحه 89-106   

نوع مقاله: Research Article

نویسنده

Sahar Dehyouri^*

Agricultural Department, Islamshahr Branch, Islamic Azad University, Islamshahr, Iran

چکیده

Rural areas have always played a significant role in the global economy by providing a variety of foods and raw materials. This role is much more prominent in developing countries. Rural development is also an important part of regional policies, covering agriculture, forestry, natural resource management, land use, and economic diversity in these areas. The present study focused on investigating rural development in rural areas of Islamshar County, Iran. Given the lack of productivity in this region and the fact that this county is so close to two metropolitan cities of Karaj and Tehran, it is necessary to examine the level of development of the villages in this county. Among various methods of ranking, the credit and point of rural development in this research were measured by AHP-based TOPSIS, factor analysis, and scale gram methods. Categorization by TOPSIS and factor analysis revealed close results considering 27 criteria for the evaluation of choices. Scale gram analysis generally confirmed these results. Also, the overall results show that the economic factor derived from the factor analysis method and the agricultural factor derived from the AHP method were acceptable. According to the viewpoint of the research population, many of the rural areas in the studied county were categorized in "deprived" group.

کلیدواژه‌ها

Classification؛ factor analysis؛ Rural Development؛ scale gram؛ TOPSIS

مراجع

Al Hassan, L. G., Umar, K. J., & Atiku, I. (2007). Nutritional evaluation of Albizia lebbeck (L.) pods as source of feeds for livestock. American Journal of Food Technology, 2 (5), 435-439

Chu, M. T., Shyu, J., Tzeng, G. H., & Khosla, R. (2007). Comparison among three analytical methods for knowledge community’s groupdecision analysis. Journal. Expert systems with Applications, 33, 1011-1024.

Eftekhari, A.R.A., Vojdani Tehrani, H., & Razini, A.A. (2009). Assessment and priority of Iranian free trade zones using MADM method. The Journal of Spatial Planning, 13(2), 142-195.

Feyzpoor, M., & Abadi, G. S. F. (2012). Labor market development in rural areas of Iran during the fourth development plan. Rural Research, 3(11), 89-112.

Ghanbari Haft Cheshmeh, A., & Hussainzadeh Dalir, H. (2005). Development determination of cities in East Azerbaijan Province (1996). Journal of Geography and Regional Development, 5, 34-47.

Gose, W.A. (2000). Palaeomagnetic Studies of Burned Rocks. Journal of Archaeological Science, 27(5), 409-421.

Hwang, C.L., & Yoon, K. (1981). Multiple Attribute Decision Making: Methods and Applications. Springer-Verlag, New York. 

Hosseinpur, Z., Menhaj, M., & Kavoosi-Kalashami, M. (2016). Assessment improving and organizing mechanism of water user’s cooperatives using AHP method in Esfarayen County, Iran. International Journal of Agricultural Management and Development, 6(3), 339-351.

Hou,Yu L. X., GAO M., & Shi ,P. (2010) Assessment of coastal zone sustainable development: A case study of Yantai, China. Ecological Indicators Journal, 10(5), 1218-1225.

Kalantari, K. (2009). Investigation of social and economic factors effective on agricultural water management knowledge of wheat producers: a case study of the Iranian city of Meshginshahr. Agricultural Extension & Education Research, 4, 21-35.

John Barry, E.K. (2001). Environment and social theory. Translated by Pouyan, H., & Tavakkoli, N. (First Ed.), Tehran: Iranian Department of Environment. 

Iravani, H., & Vafaeinejad, S.M. (2003). Investigation of rural development in Torbat Heydarieh during 1986-2000. Journal of Geographical Studies, 35(44), 41-54. 

Kalantari, K. (2009). Planning & regional development (3^rd Ed.). Tehran: Khoshbin Press.

Kalantari, K. (2003). Data processing & analysis in economic studies. Tehran: Sharif University Press.

Madhoushi, M., & Rahimikhah, M. (2009). Strategy priority in Gorgin Clay-Brick Industries Company. Management Researches Journal, 2(5), 95-117. 

Miranda, J. (1999). Evaluating sustainble agriculture utilizing multicriteria analysis: The case of Guaira. Sp, Brazil, Clark University, United State.

Mohammadi, J., Ahmadian, M., Alizadeh, J., & Jamini, D. (2012). Spatial analysis of health indices development in West Azerbaijan Province. Social Welfare, 47, 153-180.

Mahamadi, A.R., Heydari Sareban,V., Pishghar, E., & Mohamadi, F. (2016). Classification of development degree of Sub-districts in Golestan Province of Iran. Rural and Development Journal, 19(2), 1-24.

Mousavi, M., & Hekmatnia, H. (2005). Factor analysis & merged indices in determining effective factors on human development in Iranian regions. Geography & Development Iranian Journal, 6, 55-69. 

Moradi, ZH., Mirakzadeh, A., Rostami, F., & Karimi, F. (2015). Measuring of agricultural development levels in villages of qaratureh dehestan using TOPSIS Technique. Journal of Research and Rural Planning, 4(2), 21-23.

Ostovar, A. (2007). Rural poverty in developing countries. Translated by Doyay-e Eghtesad Newspaper, dated 02/05/2008.

Patrick, R. (2002). Developing sustainbility indicators for rural residentialareas:The public transit connection. Simon Fraser University, United State.

 Pezeshki, V., & Zarafshan, K. (2008). Usage of fuzzy logic in providing an evaluation model of agricultural development in villages of Kermanshah. Village & Development 4, 7-53.

Phillis,Y.A.  Kouikoglou,V. Andriantiatsaholiniaina, L.A.(2002). Sustainable development: Decision making using fuzzy logic and sensitivity analysis. Prosseding of IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics. vol 5. Yasmine Hammamet, Tunisia, Tunisia

 Pourtaheri, M., Hamdami Moghaddam, Y., & Eftekhari, R.A. (2009). Performance evaluation of Islamic Councils in rural development: a case study of Aladagh village in Bojnord. The Journal of Spatial Planning, 4(4), 23-38.

Pourtaheri, M. (2010). Using multi-attribute decision making methods in geography (First Ed.). Tehran: SAMT.

Render, B., Stair, J. R., Ralph, M. (2000). Quantitative analysis for management (7^th Ed.). Prentice-Hall, Inc: Upper Saddle River, NJ.

Rezvani, M.R., & Sahneh, B. (2005). Evaluation of rural development using fuzzy logic: A case study of villages of AQ Qala and Bandar Turkman Cities. Village & Development 3, 1-32.

Rezvani, M.R. (2002). Development investigation of provinces using Taxonomy analysis. Faculty of Literature and Humanities Journal, 12, 459-474.

Rezvani, M.R. (2004). Development evaluation and analysis of rural areas in the Iranian city of Sanandaj. Geography & Development Iranian Journal, 3, 149-164

Sarmad, Z., Bazargan, A., & Hejaz, A. (2004). Research methods in behavioral sciences (9^th Ed.). Tehran: Agah Press.

Sharama, B. (2004). Regional disparities in agricultural labour Productivity in the Brahmaputra Valley. Department of Geography, Gauhati University, Assam, India.

Sharma, H.D., & Reddy, K.R. (2004).Geoenvironmental engineering: Site remediation, waste containment, and emerging waste management technologies. Vily press, USA.

Sheykhi, H., & Shahivandi, A. (2012). Analysis of regional development and urban classification system in Zagros. The Journal of Spatial Planning, 2, 21-40.

Sheykhbeglou, R., Taghvaei, M., & Varesi, H. (2012). Spatial analysis of deprivation and development inequalities in Iranian cities. Social Welfare Quarterly, 46, 189-214.

Sirčo, A., Goss, S., Živkov, G., & Bray, T. (2013). Rural development in Bosnia and Herzegovina: Myth and Reality. National Human Development Report. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). Bosnia and Herzegovina, United Nation.

Soares, J.O, Marques, M.M.L., & Monteiro, C.M.F. (2003).A multivariate methodology to uncover regional disparities: A contribution to improve European Union and Governmental Decisions. European Journal of Operational Research, 145, 121–135.

Statistical Center of Iran (2011). Population & Housing Census. Tehran.

Tudarou, M. (1991). Economic development in the Third World.  Farjadi, G. (Trans), Tehran: Higher Institute of Research in the Planning and Development.

Voogd, H. (1983). Multicriteria evaluation for urban and regional planning. Pion, London.

Wirén, V. (2000). Sustainability in agriculture-an evaluation of principal goal oriented concepts to close the gap between theory and practice. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 84, 312-318.

Wolf, A. Zheng, T.L., Witzel, K.P., & Jost, G. (2004). Impact of initial phage/host ratio and nutrient addition on coexistence in a phage-host system. Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 35, 131-139.

 

World Bank (2015). Annual Report of 2015. The Publishing and Knowledge Division, the World Bank, 1818 H Street NW, Washington, DC 20433, USA.

Zanakis, S. H., Solomon, A., Wishart, N., & Dublish, S.  (1998). Multi-attribute decision making: A simulation comparison of select methods. European Journal of Operational Research, 107, 507-529.