Prevalence of Staphylococcus aureus in Traditional Ice Cream in Iran: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

Journal of Chemical Health Risks

دوره 13، شماره 2، شهریور 2023، صفحه 219-231   

نوع مقاله: Original Article

شناسه دیجیتال (DOI): 10.22034/jchr.2022.1915266.1222

نویسندگان

Nasim Ansari¹؛ Razzagh Mahmoudi²؛ Mehdi Yaseri³؛ Omid Khosravizadeh⁴؛ Nabi Shariatifar⁵؛ Saeed Shahsavari^{* 6}

¹Student Research Committee, School of Health, Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, Qazvin, Iran

²Medical Microbiology Research Center, Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, Qazvin, Iran

³Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

⁴Social Determinants of Health Research Center, Research Institute for Prevention of Non-Communicable Diseases, Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, Qazvin, Iran

⁵Department of Environmental Health Engineering, School of Public Health, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran

⁶Health products Safety Research Center, Qazvin University of Medical Sciences, Qazvin, Iran

چکیده

Staphylococcus aureus is known to be the third leading cause of food poisoning in the world. Traditional ice cream is one of the dairy products in Iran and some countries in the world that should be controlled for Staphylococcus aureus contamination. The purpose of this review and meta-analysis is to determine the contamination of traditional ice cream with Staphylococcus aureus in different regions of Iran. Search terms “Staphylococcus aureus”, “traditional ice Cream”, and “Iran” were used in Science Direct, Pubmed, Scopus, Google Scholar, and SID, Magiran Magazine until 2018 published without time limitation selected. To review the original articles and remove duplicate articles and review titles and abstracts, articles that have the required qualities for this research were studied in this study. Data were analyzed by the random effects model in STATA (version 11) and MedCalc (version 13) software. Publication bias and sensitivity analysis were assessed by funnel and influence plots. According to a sample size of 3811 from 35 articles, the prevalence of Staphylococcus aureus is estimated 32% in Iran (95% CI: 25-38%, p<0.001). The heterogeneity in the estimation of the pooled prevalence among the studies demonstrated; Cochran Q test: 1577.39, p< 0.001, I² = 97.84%. Based on Begg's adjusted rank correlation test, publication bias was statistically significant (p <0.05). Epidemiological data is useful to determine the distribution of Staphylococcus aureus contamination and provide a broad picture of the prevalence of traditional ice cream Iran and can be used as an important indicator in the model of risk assessment of microbiologic.

کلیدواژه‌ها

Staphylococcus aureus؛ Traditional ice cream؛ Prevalence؛ Meta-analysis

مراجع

1. Kiani A., Ahmadloo M., Moazzen M., Shariatifar N., Shahsavari S., Arabameri M., Hasani M.M., Azari A., Abdel‐Wahhab M.A., 2021. Monitoring of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and probabilistic health risk assessment in yogurt and butter in Iran. Food Science & Nutrition. 9(4), 2114-2128.
2. Kiani A., Arabameri M., Moazzen M., Shariatifar N., Aeenehvand S., Khaniki G. J., Abdel-Wahhab M., Shahsavari S., 2021. Probabilistic health risk assessment of trace elements in baby food and milk powder using ICP-OES method. Biological Trace Element Research. 1-12.
3. Kiani A., Shariatifar N., Shahsavari S., Ahmadloo M., Moazzen M., 2019. Investigating the presence of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons in Doogh. Journal of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. 29(178), 10-23.
4. Mahmoudi R., Shahsavari S., Abbasi N., Sarfalah N., 2019. Listeria monocytogenes Contamination in Unpasteurized Traditional Cheese Products in Qazvin, Iran. Journal of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. 29(178), 115-126.
5. Shahsavari S., Shariatifar N., Arabameri M., Mahmoudi R., Moazzen M., Ghajarbeygi P., 2022. Analysis of polychlorinated biphenyls in cream and ice cream using modified QuEChERS extraction and GC‐QqQ‐MS/MS method: A risk assessment study. International Journal of Dairy Technology. (In Press)
6. Velusamy V., Arshak K., Korostynska O., Oliwa K., Adley C., 2010. An overview of foodborne pathogen detection: in the perspective of biosensors. Biotechnology Advances. 28(2), 232-254.
7. Lankarani K.B., Alavian S.M., Peymani P., 2013. Health in the Islamic Republic of Iran, challenges and progresses. Medical journal of the Islamic Republic of Iran. 27(1), 42-49.
8. Daniels N. A., MacKinnon L., Rowe S.M., Bean N.H.,Griffin P.M., Mead P.S., 2002. Foodborne disease outbreaks in United States schools. The Pediatric Infectious Disease Journal. 21(7), 623-628.
9. Khoramrooz S., Sarikhani M., Khosravani S., Farhang Falah M., Mahmoudi Y., Sharifi A., 2015. Microbial contamination determination of Cream suit,Traditional Ice Cream and Olovia in Yasuj City. Armaghane Danesh. 20(6), 526-537.
10. Evenson M.L.,Hinds M.W.,Bernstein R.S., Bergdoll M.S., 1988. Estimation of human dose of staphylococcal enterotoxin A from a large outbreak of staphylococcal food poisoning involving chocolate milk. International Journal of Food Microbiology. 7(4), 311-316.
11. Baseri E., Alimohammadi M., Nabizadeh Nodehi R., Nazmara S.H., Jahed Khaniki Gh.,Mahmoodi B., 2017. Estimation of Weekly Human Intake of Heavy Metals (Lead, Cadmium, Chromium, Copper, Iron, Tin, Zinc and Nickel) Through Cheese Consumption in Iran. Journal of Health and Hygine. 8, 160-169.
12. Hazhir M.S., Rashidi K., Senobar Tahaee S.N., Reshadmanesh N., Mofareh N., 2005. Assessment of the types and rate of contamination in traditional ice-cream in Kurdistan Province and its relationship to environmental and personal health care. Scientific Journal of Kurdistan University of Medical Sciences. 10(3), 53-60.
13. Keshavarzpour Z., Sami M., Falahati H., Mohammadi R., 2016. Bacterial and mold contamination of milk and dairy products distributed by traditional or commercial producers in Isfahan, Iran, in 2014. Journal of Isfahan Medical School (I.U.M.S). 34(387), 712-717.
14. Haeri Behbahani S.B., Shahbakhti E., Moradi V., Haghani Haghighi H., Shariat S.S., Salamzadeh J., 2014. Study of the microbial contamination rate of traditional ice cream products in Tehran, March 2008- March 2011. Food Science and Technology. 11(44), 59-69.
15. Amit K.B., Pradip K.R., Subhajit R., Rakesh K., Binita R., Bipin K.S., 2017. Evaluation of microbiological quality of Ice-cream available in Kolkata and its Suburbs. The Pharma Innovation. 6(8), 377-380.
16. Almli V.L., Verbeke W., Vanhonacker F., Næs T., Hersleth M., 2011. General image and attribute perceptions of traditional food in six European countries. Food Quality and Preference. 22(1), 129-138.
17. Kanbakan U.,Çon A.H.,Ayar A., 2004. Determination of microbiological contamination sources during ice cream production in Denizli, Turkey. Food Control. 15(6), 463-470.
18. Azadnia P., ShahAhmad Ghasemi M., Abbasi M.R., Taarof N., Karimi Jashni M., 2011. Microbial Quality of Traditional Ice Cream Produced by Small-Scale Manufacturers in Khormoj and Its Comparison with the Iranian National Standard. Journal of Animal and Veterinary Advances. 10(6), 742-744.
19. Bazrafshan E., Mohammadi Girjafaki L., Mirkazehi A., Haghani H., Parvane H.R., Miri M.R., Yavari M.R., 2010. Evaluation of bacterial contamination of traditional ice cream in Zahedan during 2011-2011. Journal of Zabol University of Medical Sciences(International Journal of Basic Science in Medicine). 3(4), 19-28.
20. Shakerian A., Karim G., Tajbakhsh E., Shafei M., 2005. Investigating the microbial contamination of traditional ice creams in shahr-e-kord. Iranian Journal of Food Science and Technology. 2(4), 20-27.
21. Yaman H., Elmali M., Ulukanli Z., Tuzcu M., Genctav K., 2006. Microbial quality of ice cream sold openly by retail outlets in Turkey. Revue de médecine vétérinaire. 157(10), 457-462.
22. Shadan M., Khoushabi F., Safari F., 2003. The evaluation of physicochemical and microbial status of traditional ice creams in Zahedan. Zahedan University of Medical Sciences. 4(4), 215-221.
23. Karim G., Razavilar V., Akhondzadeh A., 1995. Survey on the contamination of Traditional Iranian ice cream with important bacteria associated with foodborn infection and intoxication. J Vet Res. 50, 1-2.
24. Rezaei M., Parviz M., Javanmard M., 2014. The Survey on the Bacterial Contamination of Traditional & Pasteurized ice Cream Produced in Arak City (summer and fall 2011). Tolooebehdasht. 13(3), 21-30.
25. Yaryar M., Ranjbari A.G., Jahromi H.K., Kalani N., 2015. Study of Listeria and E.coli, microbial load and infection in conventional ice-creams of shiraz suburb. Pars Journal of Medical Sciences. 13, 33-38.
26. Fooladi A.I., Tavakoli H., Naderi A., 2010. Detection of enterotoxigenic Staphylococcus aureus isolates in domestic dairy products. Iranian Journal of Microbiology. 2(3), 137-142.
27. Argudin M.A., Mendoza M.C., Rodicio M.R., 2010. Food poisoning and Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxins. Toxins. 2(7), 1751-73.
28. Salehi A., Dehghanifard E., Alimohammadi M., 2014. Evaluation of Coagulase-Positive Staphylococcus aureus Contamination in Lighvan Cheese on Retail Stores. Journal of Environmental Health Engineering. 1(2), 130-136.
29. Crago B., Ferrato C., Drews S.J., Svenson L.W.,Tyrrell G., Louie M., 2012. Prevalence of Staphylococcus aureus and methicillin-resistant S. aureus (MRSA) in food samples associated with foodborne illness in Alberta, Canada from 2007 to 2010. Food Microbiology. 32(1), 202-205.
30. Rahimi E., 2013. Enterotoxigenicity of Staphylococcus aureus isolated from traditional and commercial dairy products marketed in Iran. Brazilian Journal of Microbiology : [publication of the Brazilian Society for Microbiology]. 44(2), 393-399.
31. Pelisser M.R., Klein C.S., Ascoli K.R., Zotti T.R., Arisi A.C., 2009. Ocurrence of Staphylococcus aureus and multiplex pcr detection of classic enterotoxin genes in cheese and meat products. Brazilian Journal of Microbiology. 40(1), 145-158.
32. Rouhbakhsh A., 1991. Health control of food (sampling, testing, interpretation). Chehr Publishing House. 2, 127-134.
33. Fetsch A.,Contzen M., Hartelt K., Kleiser A., Maassen S., Rau J., Kraushaar B., Layer F., Strommenger B., 2014. Staphylococcus aureus food-poisoning outbreak associated with the consumption of ice-cream. International Journal of Food Microbiology. 187, 1-6.
34. Jorgensen H.J., Mork T., Hogasen H.R., Rorvik L.M., 2005. Enterotoxigenic Staphylococcus aureus in bulk milk in Norway. Journal of Applied Microbiology. 99(1), 158-66.
35. Vitale M., Scatassa M.L., Cardamone C., Oliveri G., Piraino C., Alduina R., Napoli C., 2015. Staphylococcal food poisoning case and molecular analysis of toxin genes in Staphylococcus aureus strains isolated from food in Sicily, Italy. Foodborne Pathogens and Disease. 12(1), 21-33.
36. Emami S., Akya A., Hossain Zadeh A., Barkhordar S., 2013. Bacterial contamination of traditional ice creams in Kermanshah in 2008. Iranian Journal of Medical Microbiology. 7(2), 59-62.
37. Jamali H., Paydar M., Radmehr B., Ismail S., Dadrasnia A., 2015. Prevalence and antimicrobial resistance of Staphylococcus aureus isolated from raw milk and dairy products. Food Control. 54, 383-388.
38. Arasb D.M., Madad J.S., Akbarein H., Ghanbari Sagharlou N., 2010. A bacteriological survey on traditional ice creams in retailers of Rasht (Guilan province, North of Iran) in Spring of 2009. Journal of Veterinary Laboratory Research. 2(2), 141-150.
39. Malaki M., Hashemy S., Haiemi P., Shakury F., 1970. Investigation of contaminating organisms associated with hand-made ice cream supplied in Teheran. Revue of Veterinary Faculty University of Teheran. 25 (1/2), 15-32.
40. Jazayeri S., Sadeghi Poor H., Efatpanah M., Ramin M., 2000. Microbial Contamination of Traditional Ice Cream and Homemade Juice (carrot juice and coconut milk) in the confectionery trade units and juice shop in Tehran [Online]. Hakim Health Systems Research Journal. 9-15.
41. Jamshidian M.,Taghavi S., 2001. Bacteriological Evaluation of Traditional Ice Cream in Ahwaz City. Scientific-Research Iranian Veterinary Journal. 4(7), 19-27.
42. Poormahmoodi A., Mohamadi J., Mirzaeii A., Momeninejad M., Afshar R., 2003. Microbial contamination in traditional ice cream in Yasuj, Iran 2002. Armaghane Danesh. 8(1), 59-65.
43. Mokhtarian H., Mohsenzadeh M., Khezri M., 2004. The survey on the bacterial contamination of traditional ice cream produced in Mashhad city. Ofogh-E-Danesh. 10(1), 42-46.
44. Hoveyda L., Amir Mozafari N., Forouhesh Tehrani H., 2003. Determination of Bacterial Contamination Different Ice-Creams In Tehran. Journal of Medical Council of I.R.I. 23(4), 383-390.
45. Shekarforoush S.S., Jafarpour B., 2006. Comparison of the Bacterial and Chemical Properties of Traditional Iranian Ice Cream Produced in Shiraz with IranNational Standard. Food Science and Technology. 3(9), 11-17.
46. Soltan Dallal M., Agha Amiri S., Eshraghian M., Sabour Yaraghi A., Faramarzi T., Mahdavi V., Saberpour F., Fazeli Fard P., Peymaneh ABedi Mohtasab T., 2008. Prevalence and Antibiotic Resistance Pattern of Staphylococcus aureus Strains Isolated from Food Stuff. Journal of Zanjan University of Medical Sciences. 16(64), 65-74.
47. Afraz V., Jazayery Moghadas A., Irajian G., 2009. Investigation of contamination of traditional non-pasteurized ice-creams with E.coli and Staphylococcus aureusin Semnan, Iran-year 2007-8. Iranian Journal of Medical Microbiology. 2(3), 73-77.
48. Naeimabadi A., Mirzaei R., Yazdani A., Armat M.R., Botalboluei M., Yarahmadi M., 2010. Determination of Microbial Contamination in Traditionally Manufactured Ice-Creams and Hand Made Fruit Juices in Summer 2007 and Summer 2008 In Bojnurd. Journal of North Khorasan University of Medical Sciences. 2(2), 45-50.
49. Mokhtarian H., Shariatifar N., Mohamadzadeh M., Ghahramani M., 2009. The survey on the bacterial contamination of traditional ice cream produced in Gonabad city. Quarterly of Horizon of Medical Sciences. 15(1), 45-51.
50. Sadeghi M., Amini A., Behnampour N., Ghasemi S., Arefian A., Mohajer S., 2015. Ferequency of Staphylococcus aureus in Traditional Ice Cream and Homemade Juices. Medical Laboratory Journal. 9(2), 91-96.
51. Ekhtelat M., Zaheripour Z., Shekar Riz B., 2009. The Survey on Contamination Value of Staphylococcus aureus, Coliform and E.Coli In Traditional Ice Cream Offered In Ahvaz Market. Journal of Food Hygiene. 1(3), 15-23.
52. Dabbagh M., Madad J., Akbareian H., Ghanbari S., 2010. A bacteriological survey on traditional ice creams in retailers of Rasht (Guilan province, North of Iran) in spring of 2009. Journal of Veterinary Laboratory Reaserch. 2(2), 141-150.
53. Hassanzadazar H., Abdollahi R., Haj G.G., Dalir R.M., Mehdizadeh T., 2012. Investigating of The Bacteriological Contamination In Traditionally Manufactured Ice Creams In Urmia City. Journal Food Hygiene. 2(1), 1-9.
54. Anvarinejad M.,Mirzaei H., 2013. Microbial Contamination of Traditional Ice-Creams Produced and Marketed in Maragheh During 2012. Journal of Food Hygiene. 3(11), 75-82.
55. Salehian M., Salehifar E., Esfahanizadeh M., Karimzadeh L., Rezaei R., Molanejad M., 2013. Microbial Contamination in Traditional Ice cream and Effective Factors. Journal of Mazandaran University of Medical Sciences. 23(99), 18-33.
56. Panahi N., Neiriz M., 2014. Prevalence and Patterns of Antibiotic-Resistant Coagulase - Positive Staphylococcus aureus Strains Isolated from Traditional Ice Cream City of Urmia. Nutrition and Food Sciences Research. 1(1), 211-215.
57. Navidjoy N., KarimzadehSadegh S., Dehghani A., BahramiAsl F., 2015. Study of microbial contamination in traditional ice cream (Case study: City of Urmia). Journal of Food Microbiology. 1(3), 27-32.
58. Abolhasannezhad M., Sharifzadeh G., Naseri K., Abedi A., Yosefi S., Nakhaei A., 2017. Prevalence of microbial contamination of traditional ice-creams in ice-cream supplier trade units in Birjand in 2015: Short Communication. Journal of Birjand University of Medical Sciences. 24(1), 73-78.
59. Ozra Hosseini-Naveh A.K., Azizi A., Khodadadi E., 2015. Microbial contamination of traditional ice creams in Rafsanjan, Iran. Journal of Micro Medicine. 7(1), 13-18.
60. Shahbazi Y., Emarat A., Ebrahimi F., 2015. Microbial quality and chemical composition of traditional ice cream collected from Kermanshah province, Iran. Research Opinions in Animal and Veterinary Sciences. 5(5), 237-241.
61. Ghadimi S., Heshmati A., Azizi S.M., Nooshkam M., 2017. Microbial Quality and Antimicrobial Resistance of Staphylococcus aureus and Escherichia coli Isolated from Traditional Ice Cream in Hamadan City, West of Iran. Avicenna Journal of Clinical Microbiology and Infection. 4(1), 1-6.
62. Abri R., Asghari R., Ahangarzadeh Rezaee M., 2019. High Occurrence and Antimicrobial Resistance of Staphylococcus aureus Isolates from Unpacked Ice Creams. Infection Epidemiology and Microbiology. 5(2), 25-31.
63. Samir H., Younis W., Sultan S., Abd El-Azeem M., 2018. Isolation of Staphylococcus aureus from Ice-Cream Samples. Research Animal and Veterinary. 1(2), 204-301.
64. Fadel H., Ismail J., 2009. Prevalence and significance of Staphylococcus aureus and Enterobacteriaceae species in selected dairy products and handlers. International Journal of Dairy Science. 4(3), 100-108.
65. Sobhy H., 2017. Microbial quality of street-vended ice cream. Journal of Veterinary Medical Research. 24(1), 147-155.