Evaluation of Metal Concentration (Hg, Zn, Cu, Co, Sn, Ag, Cr and Ni) in Influent & Effluent water of Dental Clinics' units

Journal of Chemical Health Risks

دوره 13، شماره 4، اسفند 2023، صفحه 653-660   

نوع مقاله: Original Article

شناسه دیجیتال (DOI): 10.22034/jchr.2022.1959189.1555

نویسندگان

Mohammadreza Malekipour Esfahani¹؛ Farzaneh Shirani^{* 2}؛ Maryam Ahmadi^{* 3}؛ Shima Ghaderi⁴

¹Department of Operative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran

²Dental Research Center, Dental Research Institute, Department of Operative Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran

³Post Graduate Student, Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Dental Students’ Research Committee, School of Dentistry, Isfahan University of Medical Sciences, Isfahan, Iran

⁴General dentist (DDS), School of dentistry, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran

چکیده

Many contaminants can enter the environment via dentistry. Some of the materials including heavy metals may present some problems to the environment. Amalgam waste in dental clinics is the main source of mercury pollution in the environment. Apart from mercury, other amalgam constituents such as Ag, Sn, Co, Cu, and Zn in dental clinics’ wastewater have just been reported in a few previous kinds of literature. This study aimed to measure the concentrations of mercury, cobalt, zinc, copper, tin, silver, chromium, and nickel in the influent and effluent of dental units of some dental clinics. Samples were collected over 6-month period from 5 dental clinics and three samples were collected from each clinic at the end of the working day, within a week as the effluent sample. Metal concentration was also detected in the influent of the dental units and samples were analysed for metals using the atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS) technique for statistical analysis. Data were analysed with Wilcoxon and Kruskal – Wallis tests within SPSS 18 software. The concentration of all the metals in influent water was at the level of the national standard in all samples. In comparing influent and effluent values, the P-values for Hg, Zn, Cu, and Sn (0.001), Cu (0.003), Ag (0.028), Cr (0.007), and Ni (0.016) as shown significant differences between influent and effluent values for all the sample. Based on the obtained findings from the study, wastewater has an undesirable level in terms of heavy metals. Thus, dental clinic wastewater might be considered hazardous waste that should be properly treated before it discharges into the environment.

کلیدواژه‌ها

Atomic absorption spectrophotometry؛ Dental amalgam؛ Dental wastewater؛ Heavy metals؛ Water pollution

مراجع

1. Shafiei M., Shafiei A., 2015. Heavy metals, sources and effects on humans. International Conference on Architecture, Urbanism, Civil, Art, Environment, Tehran, Iran.
2. Ahmadi B., 2008. The Role of Heavy Metals on Human Health. Water Resources Management Company in Iran. 1-10.
3. Karbasi M., Karbasi A., Saremi A., Ghorbani H., 2009. Investigating the concentration of heavy metals in sources of water supply in Alashtar city in 2010. J Lorestan Uni of Med Sci. 12, 65-70.
4. Singh R., Agrawal M., 2008. Potential benefits and risks of land application of sewage sludge. Waste Manag. 28, 347-58.
5. Larchevêque M., Ballini C., Korboulewsky N., Montes N., 2006. The Use of Compost in Afforestation of Mediterranean Areas Effects on Soil Properties and Young Tree Seedlings. Sciof the Total Env. 369, 220-230.
6. Rattan R.K., Datta S.P., Chhonkar P.K., Suribabu K., Singh A.K., 2005. Long-term impact of irrigation with sewage effluents on heavy metal contenting soils, crops and groundwater-a case study. Agriculture Ecosystem and Environment. 109, 310–22.
7. Ebadi F., EsmailiSari A., Riahinajiyari A., 2005. How Changes in the Amount of Heavy Metals in Sediments of Aquatic Plants in the Pond Organ Miankaleh. J of Eco, 37, 53-74.
8. Esmaeili A., 2001. Pollutants, Health and Environmental Standards. Tehran: Publication of naghshe Mehr. 305-352.
9. Shraim A., Alsuhaimi A., Al-Thakafy J.T., 2011. Dental Clinics: A Point Pollution Source, not only of Mercury but also of other Amalgam Constituents. Chemosph. 84, 1133-1139.
10. Arenholt-Bindslev D., Larsen A.H., 1996. Mercury Levels and Discharge in Waste Water from Dental Clinics.Water, Air, and Soil Pollution. 86, 93-99.
11. Berry T.G., Nicholson J., Troendle K., 1994. Almost Two Centuries with Amalgam: Where Are We Today. J Am Dent Assoc; 125:392-9.
12. Hylander L.D., Goodsite M.E., 2006. Environmental costs of mercury pollution. Sci Total Environ. 368, 352-70.
13. Velayat Z., Asgari A., Beheshti M., Mahjob S., Hosseini M., 2013. Measurement of heavy metals (cadmium, mercury, zinc, nickel, tin and iron) in canned tuna fish. Journal of Animal Science (Biology). 26, 496-506.
14. Qasim A., 2005. Industrial Toxicology. Tehran's First edition: For Tomorrow Publisher.149-129.

15.Dehghani R., 2009. Environmental Toxicology. Tehran: Takhtkord Publications. 275-250.

16. Farhadi A., Jafari M., Razavi A., 2011. Ecological Geology Survey of Siahkel 1: 50000 Sheet (Based on the Study of Geochemical Samples). J of Earth Sci. 84, 88-75.
17. Rezvani M., Ghorbanian A., Nojavan M., Sahba M., 2013. Evaluation of heavy metals contamination (Cadmium, Cobalt, Pb, Zn and Mn) in Eshtehard aquifer. J Sci and Envir Eng. 1, 13-21.
18. Shahabpoor J., 2004. Economic Geology, Third Edition. Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman Publications. pp. 543.
19. Atabey E., 2005. Medical geology. Tmmb geology muhendisler odasi publisher. Anakara. pp. 194.
20. Mohammadian M., Nouri J., Afshari N., Nassiri J., Nouran M., 2008. Investigation of Heavy Metals Concentrations in the Water Wells Close to Zanjan Zinc and Lead Smelting Plant. Ijhe. 1, 51-56.
21. Malakootian M., Mohammadi S., 2014. Quality Assessment of SIRJAN Plain Groundwater Resources to Evaluate Their Contamination to Heavy Metals at 2014. J Torbat Heydariyeh Uni of Med Sci. 2, 31-39
22. Hiltz M., 2007. The environmental impact of dentistry. J Can Dent Assoc. 73, 59-62.
23. Mebrahtu G., Zerabruk S., 2011. Concentration and Health Implication of Heavy Metals in Drinking Water from Urban Areas of Tigray Region, Northern Ethiopia. Momona Ethi J of Sci. 3, 105-21.
24. World Health Organization (WHO), 2008. Guidelines for Drinking-Water Quality., Second addendum. Vol. 1, Recommendations. 3rd ed.
25. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)., 2009. Office of Water U.S; Edition of the Drinking Water Standards and Health Advisories. EPA. 822-R-09-011, Washington, USA.
26. Leggat P.A., Kedjarune U., Smith D., 2007. Occupational health problems in modern dentistry: a review. Indus Health. 45(5), 611-21.

27. Drummond J.L., Cailas M.D., Croke K., 2003. Mercury generation potential from dental waste amalgam. J Dent. 31, 493-501.
28. Arenholt-Bindslev D., Larsen A., 1996. Mercury Levels and Discharge in Waste Water from Dental Clinics. Water, Air, and Soil Pollution. 86, 93-99.
29. Stone M.E., Cohen M., Liang L., Pang P., 2003. Determination of methyl mercury in dental-unit wastewater. Dental Materials. 19, 675-679.
30. Batchu H., Rakowski D., Fan P.L., Meyer D.M., 2006. Evaluating amalgam separators using an international standard. J Am Dent Assoc. 137, 999-1005.
31. Adegbembo A.O., 2004. Watson PA.Estimated Quantity of Mercury in Amalgam Waste Water Residue Released by Dentists into the Sewerage System in Ontario, Canada. J Can Dent Assoc. 70, 759-759.
32. Ravi G., Subramanyam R., 2012. Calcium hydroxide-induced resorption of deciduous teeth: A possible explanation. Dent Hypo. 3(3), 90.
33. Anttonen V., Tanner T., Kämppi A., Päkkilä J., Tjäderhane L., Patinen P., 2012. A methodological pilot study on oral health of young, healthy males. Dent Hypo. 3(3), 106.
34. Gupta R., Thakur N., Thakur S., Gupta B., Gupta M., 2013. Talon cusp: a case report with management guidelines for practicing dentists. Dent Hypo. 4(2), 67.
35. Kjaer I., 2013. External root resorption: Different etiologies explained from the composition of the human root-close periodontal membrane. Dent Hypo. 4(3), 75.
36. Motamedi M., Behzadi A., Khodadad N., Zadeh A., Nilchian F., 2014. Oral health and quality of life in children: a cross-sectional study. Dent Hypo. 5(2), 53.
37. Narayanan N., Thangavelu L., 2015. Salvia officinalis in dentistry. Dent Hypo. 6(1), 27.
38. Khandan A., Karamian E., & Bonakdarchian M., 2014. Mechanochemical synthesis evaluation of nanocrystalline bone-derived bioceramic powder using for bone tissue engineering. Dent Hypo. 5(4), 155.
39. Shavarani S., Nejad G., Rismanchian F., & Izbirak G., 2018. Application of hierarchical facility location problem for optimization of a drone delivery system: a case study of Amazon prime air in the city of San Francisco. The Int J of Advan Manu Tech. 95(9), 3141-3153.
40. Shirani K., Sheikhbahaei E., Torkpour Z., Nejad M., Moghadas B., Ghasemi M., Khandan A., 2020. A narrative review of COVID-19: the new pandemic disease. Ir J of Med Sci. 45(4), 233.
41. Nejad M., Alsaadi N., 2021. A fuzzy logic model and a neuro-fuzzy system development on supercritical CO₂ regeneration of Ni/Al₂O₃ catalysts. J CO₂ Util. 54, 101706.
42. Ghasemi M., Nejad M., Aghaei I., 2021. Knowledge management orientation and operational performance relationship in medical tourism (overview of the model performance in the COVID-19 pandemic and post-pandemic era). Heal Sers Manag Res. 34(4), 208-222.
43. Ghasemi M., Nejad M., Bagzibagli K., 2017. Knowledge management orientation: an innovative perspective to hospital management. Ir J of Pub Heal. 46(12), 1639.
44. Mosallaeipour S., Nejad M., Shavarani S., Nazerian R., 2018. Mobile robot scheduling for cycle time optimization in flow-shop cells, a case study. Prod Eng. 12(1), 83-94.
45. Nejad M., Güden H., Vizvári B., 2019. Time minimization in flexible robotic cells considering intermediate input buffers: a comparative study of three well-known problems. Int J of Comp Inte Manu. 32(8), 809-819.
46. Ghasemi M., Nejad M., Alsaadi N., Abdel-Jaber M., Yajid A., Shukri M., Habib M., 2022. Performance measurment and lead-time reduction in epc project-based organizations: a mathematical modeling approach. Math Prob in Eng. https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/5767356.
47. Golabi M., Nejad M., 2022. Intelligent and fuzzy UAV transportation applications in aviation 4.0. In Intelligent and Fuzzy Techniques in Aviation 4.0. Springer, Cham. pp. 431-458
48. Nejad M., Kashan A., 2019. An effective grouping evolution strategy algorithm enhanced with heuristic methods for assembly line balancing problem. J of Adv Manu Sys. 18(03), 487-509.
49. Davani P., Kloub A., Nejad M., 2020. Optimizing the first type of U-shaped assembly line balancing problems. Annals of Optimization Theory and Practice. 3(4), 65-82.
50. Saeedi M., Morovvati M., & Mollaei-Dariani B., 2020. Experimental and numerical investigation of impact resistance of aluminum–copper cladded sheets using an energy-based damage model. Journal of the Brazilian Society of Mechanical Sciences and Engineering. 42(6), 1-24.
51. Kardan-Halvaei M., Morovvati M., Mollaei-Dariani B., 2020. Crystal plasticity finite element simulation and experimental investigation of the micro-upsetting process of OFHC copper. J of Micro and Microeng. 30(7), 075005.
52. Fazlollahi M., Morovvati M., Mollaei Dariani B., 2019. Theoretical, numerical and experimental investigation of hydro-mechanical deep drawing of steel/polymer/steel sandwich sheets. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: J of Eng Manu. 233(5), 1529-1546.
53. Saeedi M., Morovvati M., Alizadeh-Vaghasloo Y., 2018. Experimental and numerical study of mode-I and mixed-mode fracture of ductile U-notched functionally graded materials. Int J of Mech Sci. 144, 324-340.
54. Morovvati M.R., Mollaei-Dariani B., 2018. The formability investigation of CNT-reinforced aluminum nano-composite sheets manufactured by accumulative roll bonding. The Int J of Adv Manu Tech. 95(9), 3523-3533.
55. Morovvati M., Dariani B., 2017. The effect of annealing on the formability of aluminum 1200 after accumulative roll bonding. J of Manu Proc. 30, 241-254.
56. Morovvati M., Lalehpour A., Esmaeilzare A., 2016. Effect of nano/micro B4C and SiC particles on fracture properties of aluminum 7075 particulate composites under chevron-notch plane strain fracture toughness test. Mat Rese Exp. 3(12), 125026.
57. Fatemi A., Morovvati M., Biglari F., 2013. The effect of tube material, microstructure, and heat treatment on process responses of tube hydroforming without axial force. The Int J of Adv Manu Tech. 68(1), 263-276.
58. Pourmoghadam M., Esfahani R., Morovvati M., & Rizi B., 2013. Bifurcation analysis of plastic wrinkling formation for anisotropic laminated sheets (AA2024–Polyamide–AA2024). Comp Mat Sci. 77, 35-43.
59. Morovvati M., Fatemi A., Sadighi M., 2011. Experimental and finite element investigation on wrinkling of circular single layer and two-layer sheet metals in deep drawing process. The Int J of Adv Manu Tech. 54(1), 113-121.
60. Morovvati M., Mollaei-Dariani B., Haddadzadeh M., 2010. Initial blank optimization in multilayer deep drawing process using GONNS. J Manu Sci Eng. 132(6).
61. Fatemi A., Biglari F., Morovvati M., 2010. Influences of inner pressure and tube thickness on process responses of hydroforming copper tubes without axial force. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part B: J of Eng Manu. 224(12), 1866-1878.
62. Anarestani S., Morovvati M., Vaghasloo Y., 2015. Influence of anisotropy and lubrication on wrinkling of circular plates using bifurcation theory. Int J of Mat Form. 8(3), 439-454.
63. Lucchini R., Carnelli D., Gastaldi D., Shahgholi M., Contro R., Vena P., 2012. A damage model to simulate nanoindentation tests of lamellar bone at multiple penetration depth. ECCOMAS. pp. 5919-5924.
64. Mahjoory M., Shahgholi M., Karimipour A., 2022. The effects of initial temperature and pressure on the mechanical properties of reinforced calcium phosphate cement with magnesium nanoparticles: A molecular dynamics approach. Int Com in Heat and Mass Trans. 135, 106067.
65. Talebi M., Abbasi Rad S., Malekzadeh M., Shahgholi M., Ardakani A., Foudeh K., Rad H., 2021. Cortical bone mechanical assessment via free water relaxometry at 3T. J Mag Res Imag. 54(6), 1744-1751.
66. Shahgholi M., Oliviero S., Baino F., Vitale-Brovarone C., Gastaldi D., Vena P., 2016. Mechanical characterization of glass-ceramic scaffolds at multiple characteristic lengths through nanoindentation. J the Eur Cer Soc. 36(9), 2403-2409.
67. Fada R., Farhadi N., Azimi R., Karimian M., Shahgholi M., 2021. Mechanical properties improvement and bone regeneration of calcium phosphate bone cement, Polymethyl methacrylate and glass ionomer. J Nanoanal. 8(1), 60-79.
68. Malekipour M., Norouzi Z., Shahlaei S., 2019. Effect of remineralizing agents on tooth color after home bleaching. Fron in Dent. 16(3), 158.
69. Malekipour M., Shirani F., Taromi Z., Shahnazari S., 2017. Comparison of color stability of two resin composites in blood area. Dental Hypotheses. 8(3), 65.
70. Malekipour M., Shirani F., Ebrahimi M., 2016. The effect of washing water temperature on resin-dentin micro-shear bond strength. Dent Res J. 13(2), 174.
71. Ramezani M., Ghalenoei M., 2020. Determination of Trace Amount of Manganese‎ in Water Samples by Micro-funnel Magnetic Stirring-assisted Liquid Phase Microextraction Technique. J Chem Heal Risks. 10(3), 213-224